Early Stage Career

Mastering Your First End-of-Year Review: A Comprehensive Guide

Showcase your achievements, seek constructive feedback, and pave the way for a successful career during your review.
July 27, 2023
Lorem ipsum sit dolor et sua vous.

Whether you're preparing for your first end-of-year review in a full-time, part-time, or internship position, these evaluations play a crucial role in gathering feedback, discussing promotions, and negotiating salary increases. 

If you're approaching this process with a mix of excitement and anxiety, fear not. With the right approach and preparation, you can turn this potentially nerve-wracking experience into an opportunity for personal and professional growth. 

What is an End of Year Review?

An End of Year Review is a formal assessment conducted by employers to evaluate an employee's performance over the past year. It's a pivotal moment for entry-level talent to showcase their contributions, growth, and achievements. During this review, both the employee and their manager discuss accomplishments, areas for improvement, and set goals for the upcoming year. It's an opportunity to reflect on your career trajectory, receive constructive feedback, and align on expectations. Excelling in this review can open doors to promotions, salary increases, and professional development opportunities, making it a critical juncture for setting the foundation of your career path.

Before the EOY Review


Before you even step into the review meeting, take some time to reflect on your performance over the past year. What were your accomplishments and areas where you could have improved? Consider how you've contributed to your team and the organization's goals. Having a clear understanding of your own strengths and weaknesses will help you set the stage for a productive discussion during your review.

Consider how your contributions have supported your team and the organization's broader goals. Having a clear understanding of your strengths and areas that need work will set the stage for a productive discussion during your review.

Gather Documentation

Compile a folder or digital document that showcases your accomplishments throughout the year, even better if you've been keeping a work wins tracker. Include specific examples of projects you've completed successfully, emails or feedback from colleagues or clients praising your work, and any metrics or data demonstrating your contributions. Having this evidence on hand can be incredibly beneficial when discussing your achievements during the review.

Prepare Thoughtful Questions

Your end-of-year review isn't just an opportunity for your manager to evaluate your performance; it's also a chance for you to gain insights into your career development. Prepare a list of relevant questions to ask during the review, such as, "What skills should I focus on developing in the coming year?" or "Are there new projects or responsibilities I can take on to contribute more to the team?" Showing your interest in personal and professional development demonstrates your commitment to the organization.

Review Your Goals

If you set goals or objectives with your manager at the beginning of the year, review them before your end-of-year review. Evaluate your progress toward these goals and be ready to discuss any challenges you encountered and how you overcame them. Goal achievement is often a key component of performance evaluations, so demonstrating progress is essential.

During the EOY Review

Actively Engage

During the review, expect to receive feedback from your manager, both positive and constructive. Be prepared to ask follow-up questions to clarify what your manager considers optimal performance. Together, you and your manager may create action plans to enhance or sustain your performance in the upcoming year.

Discuss Raises

If your company doesn't have a set process for raises, your review provides an appropriate platform to discuss the possibility of a salary increase or promotion. Approach this conversation professionally and confidently, as it's a standard part of the review process.

Stay Positive and Open-Minded

Receiving feedback, especially constructive criticism, can be challenging. However, it's crucial to approach the review with a positive mindset and an open attitude. Embrace feedback as an opportunity for learning and growth. Remember that the review's goal is not only to highlight your strengths but also to identify areas for improvement and development.

Post EOY Review

Seek Continuous Feedback

Don't wait for the official review to seek feedback. Throughout the year, proactively request input from your manager, colleagues, and peers. This ongoing feedback loop helps you identify areas for improvement and make necessary adjustments in real time, laying the foundation for your personal growth.

Take Action

After your end-of-year review, it's essential to follow up with a plan of action. If you and your manager discussed specific areas for improvement or development, create a plan to address them. Set SMART (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound) goals to track your progress throughout the year.

You Got This!

Nailing your first end-of-year review is all about preparation, self-awareness, and a commitment to growth. By reflecting on your performance, gathering evidence, seeking feedback, and maintaining a positive attitude, you can turn your review into a productive and valuable experience. Remember that this is an opportunity not only to showcase your achievements but also to set the stage for your future success within the organization. Approach it with confidence and a growth mindset, and you'll be well on your way to a successful review and a successful career.

If you liked this article, join 100k+ readers receiving the Edge - our weekly newsletter featuring insider tips and tricks on everything you need to know to land your dream job… and how to keep it.

Ready to get started?

Learn how externships can help your business and students prosper.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.